Dear Editor,
President Jagdeo has finally confirmed that he has acquired land in Pradoville 2. He described the price as $5 million per acre without stating how many acres he bought. The word is that it was 2.5 acres of land, which if true is arguably the largest single plot of land by any individual in any residential area in Guyana.
Mr Jagdeo had been among the favoured comrades and strategic individuals to receive an allocation of land in Pradoville 1. He did not build until several years later, rented the house no doubt for a decent rent, and later sold it for a substantial gain. Soon after, in negotiations in which he was influential as both buyer and seller, he acquired land in Pradoville 2 at a concessionary price.
The President enjoys the following exemptions from taxes under the law:
1. on his official emoluments under the Income Tax Act;
2. from all customs duties under the Customs Act;
3. from all obligations under the Property Tax Act;
4. from all obligations under the Capital Gains Tax Act.
Under the Former Presidents (Benefits and other Facilities) Act 2009 in which he was not in an insignificant conflict, Mr Jagdeo will enjoy those exemptions plus a substantial pension and other benefits until death, or until the earlier repeal of the act.
Let us look first at tax issues facing Mr Jagdeo. Since rental is not official emoluments, the net rental income from the Pradoville 1 house is taxable. But Mr Jagdeo’s tax exposure does not end there. He never lived in that house, used it as a commercial venture and then made a substantial profit on its sale. After further consideration and research, I have revised my earlier suggestion (Business Page October 31, 2010) that the gain would be subject to Capital Gains Tax except for the exemption stated at 4 above. It is now my considered view that on a proper interpretation and application of the tax laws, the gain is taxable as income under the Income Tax Act despite the fact that it arose from what would be described as an isolated transaction.
Now to Mr Jagdeo’s land dealings. The standard clauses in transports for the purchase of land in government schemes include:
a) The purchaser must build within twelve months of the passing of transport. Any person failing to do so is bound to re-convey the property to the Central Housing and Planning Autho-rity, subject to be reimbursed with a reasonable sum for any development works undertaken during such period.
b) The purchaser cannot sell, lease, transfer or otherwise dispose of the said property within ten years from the date of transport, without the written consent of the Minister responsible for Housing. If the person wants to do so, the Central Housing and Planning Authority must be given the first option to buy.
c) Anyone who owns real property is not entitled to purchase a lot. If it is found out that the person had owned real property within the past three years he is liable to pay to the Government of Guyana or Central Housing and Planning Authority the current market value of the lot or at its option, the Government of Guyana will be entitled to repossess the said lot upon the repayment of the purchase money less expenses incurred for repossession.
That Mr Jagdeo did not build within twelve months; that he earned rentals; and that he made a gain of approximately $100 million on the sale of the Pradoville property are hardly matters of dispute. He is therefore in breach of the condition under the Pradoville 1 transport and has tax obligations in connection with the property he owned and sold there.
Mr Jagdeo’s attorney may want to make the slick argument that Pradoville 2 is not subject to the rules that apply to government lands. But no one can dispute the arithmetic that 2.5 acres of land in the Eccles housing area (Block A) and comparable land at Diamond would fetch $10 million per acre. It is clear then that $12.5 million for 2.5 acres of ocean front land in the far more exclusive Pradoville 2 cannot be justified and Mr Jagdeo of all people must know this.
When around 1970 then Minister of Works Hydraulics and Supply Hamilton Green acquired government-owned metal sheets to paal off his private property, the PPP, the Catholic Church, the TUC, professionals and all decent-minded Guyanese were outraged. At the instance of Eusi Kwayana, the Ombudsman investigated the matter and exonerated Green. Contrast that with Mr Jagdeo’s shocking and secretive acquisition, contempt for the dignity of the highest office in the land, disdain for the opinion of the people, making a joke of the Norwegians and the United Nations Champion of the Earth award, and the threat and fear of rising sea levels that Jagdeo’s land deals epitomise. It is doubtful that even Burnham knew the possibilities for misuse that his 1980 constitution offered. Hoyte and the two Jagans obviously did not contemplate it. It has taken thirty years and a Bharrat Jagdeo for those possibilities to be exploited to this degree. And we have not seen the end. As a result of his Former Presidents Benefits Act, taxpayers will have to meet for the rest of his life the cost of the maids, gardeners, water, electricity and telephones for a property that under any standards of decency would be considered with more than mere suspicion.
Yours faithfully,
Christopher Ram